18 Best Christmas Cookies to Make for a Holiday Cookie Exchange

This post may contain affiliate links, which means we’ll receive a commission if you purchase through our link, at no extra cost to you. See our disclosure here.

best christmas cookie recipes

There’s something about the holidays that makes baking feel a little sweeter — especially when there are cookies involved. One of my absolute favorite Christmas traditions is a Christmas cookie exchange, where everyone brings a batch of their favorite homemade treats to share and leaves with a heaping plate of cookies to enjoy.

Whether you’re attending a neighborhood cookie swap, hosting a holiday gathering, or simply looking for a few festive recipes to bake and share this season, I’ve rounded up some of the best cookie recipes that are delicious and festive additions to your holiday cookie tray. Keep reading to find the perfect recipes to make and save in your recipe box this year.

1. Christmas Sugar Cookies

best christmas cookie recipes

These holiday sugar cookies are perfect for a fun bake night with friends, holiday cookie exchanges, or for gifting coworkers or neighbors. They’re fun, simple, and look like holiday magic. They’re a classic staple that will spread some holiday cheer!

2. Chocolate Peppermint Cookies

best christmas cookie recipes

Not only do these cookies get Santa’s seal of approval, but they are also one of the most delicious cookies you’ll ever taste.The chocolate cookie tastes like a chewy, doughy chocolate delight. It’s lightly dipped in white melting chocolate and sprinkled with crushed candy cane. So delicious!

3. Pistachio Shortbread Cookies

pistachio shortbread, best christmas cookie recipes

These pistachio shortbread cookies are the perfect butter cookie for pretty much any occasion — the holidays, dinner parties, or to keep in the cookie jar throughout the year. The addition of the crushed pistachios adds a nutty flavor that balances beautifully with the buttery, sweet cookie.

4. Lemon Snowball Cookies

lemon snowball cookies

These snowball cookies are super easy to make with just a handful of ingredients that you likely already have on hand!! Each cookie is rolled in powdered sugar, making them look like snowballs, which makes them a festive treat for the holiday season. 

5. Red Velvet Marshmallow Cookies

best christmas cookie recipes

Growing up, our mom always made red velvet cake for neighbors and friends. It became a tradition and a flavor we always looked forward to most this time of year.

To pay homage to our nostalgia and our mom’s love for red velvet, we created these Red Velvet Marshmallow cookies. They are a chewy, slightly doughy red velvet cookie with marshmallow cream bursting from the inside.

6. Glazed Maple Oatmeal Cookies

best christmas cookie recipes

There is something about an oatmeal cookie that seems to soothe the soul with each bite. The mixture of the warm oats and brown sugar dough makes them so comforting. And the addition of maple glaze and sea salt to these cookies takes them to a whole other level. They’re an indulgent treat to enjoy with a cup of coffee at dinner or to share with friends.

7. Glazed Chocolate Oatmeal Cookies

glazed chocolate oatmeal cookies, best christmas cookie recipes

A classic oatmeal cookie dressed in chocolate. It’s a classic for chocolate lovers. Each cookie is filled with hearty old-fashioned oats, blended with cocoa powder, and cooked to chewy perfection and dipped in a vanilla powdered sugar glaze. The result feels familiar but is a bit more indulgent. 

8. Raspberry White Chocolate Cookies

raspberry white chocolate cookies, best christmas cookie recipes

A simple vanilla cookie dough, studded with white chocolate chips and swirled with raspberries, makes an irresistible sweet, slightly tart cookie. The freshness of the berries mixed with the soft, sweet baked dough is perfectly balanced in flavors and textures. It’s also a beautiful dessert to present on a Christmas cookie exchange platter.

9. The Best Snickerdoodle Cookies

snickerdoodle cookies

The best snickerdoodle cookies are soft and chewy on the inside and slightly crunchy on the edges. But what makes these cookies so delicious is the soft center packed with cinnamon and a generous coating of cinnamon sugar on the outside. The defining ingredient in all snickerdoodle cookies is cream of tartar, which gives the cookies a slightly tangy taste.

10. Spiced Gingerbread Cookies

spiced gingerbread cookies, best christmas cookie recipes

These spiced gingerbread cookies have a strong punch of ginger and other warming spices like cinnamon and cardamom to give them that cozy holiday taste that you dream of. This recipe creates the perfect soft cookie, with the key ingredient here is blackstrap molasses. It’s strong, rich flavor gives the cookies a deeper flavor. And each cookie is finished with a spiced powdered sugar glaze that adds the perfect, sweet finish.

11. Brown Butter Chocolate Pistachio Cookies

Brown butter chocolate pistachio cookies

Soft, doughy brown butter cookie dough filled with rich dark chocolate, pistachio pieces, and topped with pistachio butter and flaky sea salt. These brown butter chocolate pistachio cookies are the super extra cousin to your favorite chocolate chip cookie. It’s a delicious addition to your Christmas cookie lineup.

12. The Most Delicious Christmas M&M Cookies

best christmas cookie recipes

When we say these are the best M&M cookies you will ever taste, we aren’t joking! They are the perfect combination of chewy and soft, and have the delicious M&M candies throughout.

13. New York-Style Black & White Cookies

new york-style black and white cookies

We’re bringing Big City Energy straight to your kitchen with these homemade New York-Style Black and White Cookies. This iconic bakery staple is surprisingly easy to make and tastes just like the real deal!

Each soft, cake-like almond cookie is pillowy soft, just like you would get at a New York bakery. And each one is finished with the classic half-and-half look â€“ rich chocolate icing on one side and vanilla icing on the other. 

14. Mini Frosted Sprinkle Cookies

mini frosted sprinkle cookies

These miniature, colorful cookies are small, but they deliver a big personality in every bite. They start with a simple vanilla cookie dough before it’s cut into small shapes. Each one is topped with vanilla or chocolate icing and finished with a pinch of sprinkles. 

Pro tip: Add red or green food coloring to the vanilla frosting and decorate the cookies with festive holiday sprinkles.

15. Biscoff White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies

best christmas cookie recipes

We have given the outdated white chocolate macadamia nut cookies a mouth-watering revamp with a couple of secret ingredients. A buttery spiced cookie dough filled with white chocolate, macadamia nuts, and coconut. You’re going to love these Biscoff white chocolate macadamia nut cookies!

16. Cranberry Crumble Bars

cranberry crumble bars, best christmas cookie recipes

A homemade spiced shortbread crust and crumble with a layer of bright red homemade cranberry jam. The tart cranberry jam is the perfect balance with the sweet, spiced shortbread layers. 

These crumble bars are so beautiful they can even be packaged to make for a homemade gift for the foodie friend. 

17. Little Debbie Christmas Dessert Bars

Little Debbie Christmas Dessert Bars, best christmas cookie recipes

These Little Debbie Christmas Dessert Bars take the iconic holiday snack cake but glowed up! A soft vanilla blondie base, fluffy whipped icing, and coated with white chocolate. Of course, we couldn’t forget to decorate with the classic red stripes and green sprinkles.

18. No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel Bars

best christmas cookie recipes

While these aren’t technically Christmas cookies, they definitely deserve their moment in the spotlight. These no-bake dessert bars are made with a peanut butter base that’s sprinkled with crushed pretzels for a salty crunch. The bars are topped with a creamy chocolate-peanut butter layer and a toss of holiday sprinkles on top.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.